Monday, August 31, 2009

Rise of Plagiosphere & Ecstasy of Influence

Every time I type a paper for school, I constantly have the thought running in my mind, “What if this was already said?”. I would never intentionally plagiarize in my school work or in any other type of writing, first of all because the consequences are harmful and second because I have no need to. I am able to read something and summarize my own thoughts about the work, but what if how I summarize something or the ideas I acquire from a certain work I have read, is the same way someone else already has? In this never ending world called the Web, people are constantly posting their thoughts and ideas, and we are bound to run into someone who feels the same way we do. The article called “The Rise of Plagiosphere”, mentions the Turnitin program that many professors have begun using. Yes, this is a good idea if a student is stupid enough to copy an entire text and say it was his own words, but when it comes to small phrases, I hope they don’t think I am plagiarizing because ultimately I am probably going to have the same thing to say as someone else once did. It’s almost impossible not to plagiarize some one’s words, because someone somewhere has probably already thought or said what you already have. The article titled, “Ecstasy of Influence”, depicts how some newer pieces of work, such as movies, cartoons, and books, have been influenced by older works. I see no problem with this. The world would never grow and improve without people sharing their ideas and learning from others to be inspired to contribute their own thoughts. Our ideas must start somewhere, and somewhere is most likely form someone else’s thoughts. This article also talks about the commons, which is something that everyone can share. I see our blogs and any one else’s blogs like the commons. We are free to express our own ideas and thoughts and learn from others without being worried about how we say something and if it has already been said. I think we must have caution when writing on the Web, we must realize what we say will be seen by others and might even be used by others. But isn’t that the whole reason we write? Don’t we want people to hear us and take something out of it? No, I don’t want someone to take credit for an entire essay I wrote, but if they see something they like and can expand on it, that’s the reason I wrote it in the first place.

5 comments:

  1. I agree that it is impossible not to use at least some phrases that have been written in the past.I also agree that people should use the thoughts and words of others in order for our world to grow and improve. I think that using internet sources, such as blogs, is a great way to communicate our ideas. However, it becomes almost impossible to take ownership of our words when so many other people are likely thinking about and writing on the same topics.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It's a curious fear in a way, since plagiarism would seem to assume intention to make someone else's words your own, but what you describe makes sense, as well, in a world where there is so much writing and all of it interconnected. That is, unintentional plagiarism is possible, perhaps even likely with the tight network writings out there. But does this mean that the value of written expression changes? If it's so easy to get others words and rework them, does any individual work lose its value? And, if so, what becomes the standard of value.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also wonder when I am writing a paper if what I have written was already said somewhere else. There are so many published/copy righted works in our world. After reading the article, I will be checking my future papers in search engines to make sure what I have written isn't published anywhere else.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree. In modern English, there are only about so many ways to say certain things. I hope those spider programs are not picking out things as being paraphrases that are not actually meant to be paraphrases, but actually coincidental similarities.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with and enjoyed the way in which you summed up the topic of teachers using Turnitin to check for plagiarism. Whenever I start writing, I also find myself thinking those thoughts you posted at first. I have to keep this short, but I just wanted to thank you for saying the comment about the teachers...

    ReplyDelete